|
ABSTRACT
Background
and objectives:
Sudden drop in blood pressure may predispose some
elderly people to symptomatic hypotension leading
to syncope, fall and fractures. Those symptoms
can easily be overlooked in the elderly, and they
can be attributed to ageing, without expecting
a possible decline in the role of the autonomic
nervous system in the cardiovascular responses.
The main objective of the present study was mainly
concerned to test for the first time, any significant
postural or postprandial hypotension in the healthy
elderly Saudi population.
Methods:
Forty-nine >65-year
olds, and forty-five <40 year old young
adults, were selected for the study.
Parameters
of heart rate, systolic and diastolic blood pressures,
and ECG for each subject were recorded by Dinamap
(an automatic recorder).
Results:
The postural changes of blood pressure and heart
rate were highly significant in the elderly compared
to the young adults, both in the pre-meal and
postprandial periods.
Conclusion:
The marked postural changes in blood pressure
and heart rate in the healthy elderly can be explained
only by a defect in the reaction of the cardiovascular
system in response to physiologic stimuli such
as standing upright or taking a meal.
|
- - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
INTRODUCTION
Orthostatic and postprandial
hypotension is a physical finding, not a disease, and
may be symptomatic or asymptomatic. It can occur in
all age groups, but is more frequent in the elderly
than in young or middle-aged groups (Manica et al. 1990).
It is defined as a decrease in systolic blood pressure
of at least 20 mmHg, or a decrease of diastolic blood
pressure of at least 10 mmHg within three minutes of
standing (The American Autonomic Society, 1996). Autonomic
control of cardiovascular responses to postural changes
in older individuals is of considerable importance in
helping to assess the cardiovascular potential in the
elderly. Diseases which may decrease cerebral blood
flow, like hypertension, diabetes mellitus, heart disease
and hyperlipidemia are more frequent in the elderly,
which make them more vulnerable to cerebral ischemia
and syncope if their blood pressure decreases. The symptoms
of hypotension may go unnoticed or ignored and may lead
to repeated falls and trauma. Additionally it may lead
to psychological loss of confidence causing immobility
and prolongation of rehabilitation, and sometimes to
depression.
The present investigation was concerned mainly with
testing this important autonomic cardiovascular reflex
in the healthy elderly Saudi Population. No previous
study has reported the incidence of orthostatic hypotension
in this population.
The autonomic nervous system is a crucial system for
maintenance of homeostasis. Progressive dysfunction
in this system was reported in several studies in elderly
people and in old animals. In healthy elderly subjects,
facial cooling in air produces a greater increase in
blood pressure and a smaller bradycardia than in young
control subjects (Collins et al. 1989). Changes of cold
pressor reflexes and thermoregulatory reflexes were
reported in several studies (Eckberg et al. 1992) (Collins
et al.1995, 1996). Abdel-Rahman et al. 1992, 1993).
Orthostatic hypotension had been observed in all age
groups, and it found to occur more frequently in the
elderly, especially in persons who were sick and frail
(Mader et al. 1987) (Ooi et al.1997).
A fall in systolic blood pressure of 20 mmHg or diastolic
blood pressure of 10 mmHg on standing was reported to
occur in 6-30 % of elderly people (Petersen et al. 2000)
(Sumiyoshi et al. 1999). It was shown to be associated
with increased rate of falls, and a history of myocardial
infarction or transient ischemic attack (Rutan et al.
1992). It may also be predictive of ischemic stroke
(Eigenbrodt et al. 2000). The decrease of blood pressure
following upright tilt was found to be a useful predictor
of falls in older people (Edward et al. 2002).
Autonomic response to standing was found to be related
to changes in plasma norepinephrine level (Ziegler M.G.
1980). Standing evokes diffuse increases in sympathetic
nervous activity with enhanced release of norepinephrine,
however this increase was not found in some patients
with orthostatic hypotension (Lye et al. 1990). Low
supine plasma norepinephrine level or a subnormal rise
in the norepinephrine level on standing were reported
to serve as biochemical markers of peripheral autonomic
failure (Polinsky RJ. 1990).
It was reported that when an adult stands from a lying
position, 300 to 800 ml of blood pools in the lower
extremities (Lipsitz LA. 1989) (Weiling et al. 1993).
To maintain blood pressure, this position change requires
several sensitive responses to occur quickly. These
responses were found to include Cardiovascular, neurologic,
muscular, and neurohumoral factors (Weiling et al. 1993).
Dysfunction of any of these factors can lead to reduction
in blood pressure and oxygen perfusion, which can lead
to dizziness and faints, which may cause falls and fractures.
The autonomic nervous system plays an important role
in maintaining blood pressure when a person changes
position. The baroreceptors can sense the slightest
drop in blood pressure which can lead to increased sympathetic
tone leading to vasoconstriction, and increase in heart
rate and cardiac contractility.
These
changes can maintain blood pressure and perfusion.
Further studies of heart rate variability in the elderly
using Power Spectral Analysis will add more information
to the cardiovascular reflexes in this group.
METHODS
Dinamap (an Automatic
blood pressure and heart rate recorder), which can also
monitor subcutaneous oxygen tension (SPO2), the
respiratory rate and record an ECG, was used in this
study. This machine resolved many of the problems of
blood pressure recording, including observer bias.
We excluded from our study the extremely elderly individuals
more than 75 years old, and those subjects with a history
of cardiovascular disease like supine hypertension,
or heart failure, or those with any disorder associated
with autonomic dysfunction like diabetes, or history
of syncope, or those with other major illness, or those
using vasodilator drugs. We included in our study all
those volunteers, who were reasonably healthy. All subjects
selected were employees in King Saud University. The
nature of the test was explained to all subjects after
their consent was obtained before their participation
in the study. Forty-nine >65-year olds, and
forty- five <40-year olds were willing to
volunteer in the study.
Each subject attended the laboratory three hours after
a light breakfast. Subjects rested supine for at least
10 minutes. Then parameters of heart rate, systolic,
diastolic, and mean blood pressure, ECG, were recorded
by the Dinamap (an Autonomic recorder of all those parameters).
Those readings were taken after resting for 10 minutes
in the supine position, and then after one, and two
minutes of standing up from the supine position. Then
a standard meal was provided to each subject, and after
45 minutes all parameters were recorded by the Dinamap
after 10 minutes in the supine position, and then after
one and two minutes of standing up. All subjects were
able to perform the standing test with not much difficulty.
Statistical Methods:
We used student t-test for matched pairs to compare
each variable in the supine position with the standing
position in the two groups.
We used also student t-test for independent groups to
compare each variable between elderly group (n 49) and
young adults (n 45), in the supine and standing positions
both in the pre-meal and post-prandial periods. We studied
also the changes in the heart rate, systolic and diastolic
blood pressure from the supine position to the standing
position in the pre-meal and post-prandial periods,
and we compared those between the elderly and young
adults.
We used SPSS statistical package version 10.01 for data
analysis.
Results were expressed
as mean values standard deviation.
RESULTS
The physical characteristics
of the elderly and young adults are shown in
Table 1.
|
Variables
|
Young
adults
>40-year olds
n = 45
|
Elderly
subjects
<65-year olds
n = 49
|
Significant
Relationship
|
| Age (Years) |
28.6 ± 7.6
|
67.9 ± 2.4
|
P < 0.0001
|
| Weight (Kg) |
75.7 ± 12.9
|
81.6 ± 15.5
|
N S
|
| Height (cm) |
166.6 ± 7.3
|
161.5 ± 9.0
|
P < 0.0003
|
Table 1: Physical Characteristics
of Young adults and Elderly subjects
Mean ± SD.
The mean resting heart rate
was significantly high (P<0.ooo5) in the healthy
elderly (n=49), compared to the young adults (n=45),
in the standing or supine positions, both in the pre-meal
and postprandial periods, Table 2.
| Pre
- Meal period |
Postprandial
period |
| Variables |
Young adults
>40 years
n = 45
|
Elderly
subjects
<65 years
n = 49
|
Significant
Relationship
|
Young adults
>40 years
n = 45
|
Elderly subjects <65
n = 49
|
Significant
Relationship
|
| Heart Rate
(SP) |
72.3 ±
6.1
|
91 ±
7.5
|
P < 0.0004
|
74.6 ±
6.1
|
89.6 ±8.2
|
P < 0.0004
|
| Heart Rate
(ST) |
76.8 ±
5.8
|
93.1 ±
6.8
|
P < 0.0005
|
78.5 ±
5.8
|
92.3 ±
6.9
|
P < 0.0005
|
Systolic B.P
(SP) mmHg
|
129.2 ±
9.4
|
161.4 ±
24.5
|
P < 0.0006
|
130.4 ±
9.4
|
155.4 ±
22.6
|
P < 0.0006
|
Systolic B.P
(ST) mmHg
|
126.6 ±
9.4
|
133.4 ±
19.5
|
NS
|
129 ±
9.4
|
129.9 ±
18.4
|
NS
|
| Diastolic B.P
(SP) mmHg |
74.0
|
80.8 ±
8.0
|
P < 0.0008
|
73.8 ±
6.1
|
80.3 ±
8.3
|
P < 0.0008
|
| Diastolic B.P
(ST) mmHg |
75 ±
5.8
|
75.3 ±
10.0
|
NS
|
74 ±
5.8
|
76.3 ±
7.6
|
NS
|
Table 2: Pre-meal and postprandial
systolic, diastolic blood pressures, and heart rate,
in the supine (SP) and standing (ST) positions in the
young adults >40-year
olds, and the elderly subjects <65-year
olds.
In comparison between mean systolic and diastolic blood
pressures in the young adults and elderly subjects,
the result showed that the mean systolic and diastolic
blood pressures were significantly high in the elderly
(n=49), compared to the young adults (n=45), in the
supine position, both in the pre-meal and postprandial
periods (P<0.0006), Table 2. However, when standing,
the mean systolic and diastolic blood pressures were
comparable between the two groups, and there were no
significant differences between them. That can be explained
by the greater drop in blood pressure in the elderly
group in the standing position, Table 2.
Comparisons between the mean postural changes in systolic,
diastolic blood pressures, and heart rate from the supine
position to the standing position in the elderly group
compared to the young adults were highly
significant (P<0.0004), both in the pre-meal and
postprandial periods, Table 3.
| Variables |
Groups |
Mean changes ± SD |
Significant relationship |
Systolic B.P. mmHg
(Pre-meal)
|
Young
Elderly
|
2.6± 0.8
28 ± 1.7
|
P < 0.0004 |
Systolic B.P. mmHg
(Postprandial)
|
Young
Elderly
|
1.4 ± 0.8
25.5 ± 1.4
|
P < 0.0004 |
Diastolic B.P.
mmHg
(Pre-meal)
|
Young
Elderly
|
-0.7 ± 0.5
5.5 ± 0.7
|
P < 0.0004 |
Diastolic B.P mmHg
(Postprandial)
|
Young
Elderly
|
-0.29 ± 0.6
4.3 ± 0.8
|
P < 0.0004 |
Heart Rate
(Pre-meal)
|
Young
Elderly
|
-4.5 ± 0.7
-2 ± 0.6
|
P < 0.0004 |
Heart Rate
(Postprandial)
|
Young
Elderly
|
-3.9 ± 0.6
-2.7 ± 0.6
|
P < 0.0004 |
Table 3: Mean postural changes
of systolic, diastolic blood pressures, and heart rate
in the young adults <40-year olds (n = 45),
and the elderly subjects >65- year olds (n
= 49), in the pre-meal and postprandial periods. Mean
± SD
DISCUSSION
The finding of our investigation indicated a highly
significant postural drop in the mean systolic blood
pressure of the healthy elderly subjects, compared to
a very small and insignificant drop in the young adults
as shown in Tables 2 and 3. The drop in systolic blood
pressure in the elderly group confirmed the conclusions
of several other studies (Mancia et al. 1990) (Ferrari
et al. 1989) (Mader et al. 1987) (Ooi et al.1997). Up
to about 30% of elderly subjects were reported to experience
significant drop in systolic blood pressure on standing
(Petersen et al. 2000).
The mean postural drop in systolic
blood pressure in our study ranges between 25-28 mmHg
(Table 3), which was greater than those changes reported
in the literature (Macrae et al. 1989) (Mo R et al.
1994). These differences may be attributed to variations
in standardization of procedures, and also may be due
to the higher environmental temperature in our area,
compared to those areas where previous studies in the
literature were conducted. The increased activity of
the sweat glands at higher environmental temperatures
may contribute to a greater postural changes in blood
pressure.
The increase in heart rate
on standing was less and insignificant in the elderly
group compared to the young group. The increase of heart
rate on standing was related to changes in plasma norepinephrine
level (Ziegler MG 1980) and that increase was not found
in some patients with orthostatic hypotension (Lye M
et al. 1990). Our study also demonstrated a higher resting
heart rate in the elderly group >65 years,
compared to the young adults <40 years, both
in the supine and standing positions as shown in Table
2. It was reported that heart rate variability was diminished
with advancing age by using Power Spectral Analysis
(Korkushko et al. 1991). In animal studies, arterial
baroreflex control of heart rate, and arterial blood
pressure, were all significantly diminished in older
animals (Hajduczok et al. 1991). In the elderly, there
appears to be a decline in parasympathetic function
which controls the heart rate during rest and this may
explain the higher resting heart rate in the elderly
group. The decreased compliance of the baroreceptors
and the impaired vagal activity in the elderly were
also reported in other studies (Collins et al.1995,
1996).
To show further the effects of ageing in our study,
we compared the mean supine and standing heart rate,
systolic and diastolic blood pressures between the healthy
young adults <40 years (n 45), and the healthy
elderly people >65 years (n 49), in the pre-meal
and postprandial periods. The results showed significant
differences between the two groups in all variables
in the supine position (P<0.0004). However, when
standing, the mean systolic and diastolic blood pressure
were comparable between the two groups and there were
no significant differences between them as in Table
2. That can be explained by the greater drop in the
mean systolic and diastolic blood pressures in the elderly
group when standing, compared to a very small change
in the young group.
Our investigation demonstrated a defect in the reaction
of the cardiovascular system in esponse to physiological
stimuli such as standing upright or taking a meal in
the elderly group compared to the young group. That
defect was shown by a significant drop in the mean systolic
blood pressure on standing, and ere consistent with
several previous studies on the changes of the cardiovascular
reflexes with ageing (Eckberg et al. 1992) (Collins
et al.1995) (Petersen et al. 2000) (Sumiyoshi et al.
1999). The significant drop in systolic blood pressure
observed in our elderly subjects was generally asymptomatic,
however that did not exclude symptoms occurring in the
same individual at different times of the day. It was
reported that the decrease in blood pressure following
upright tilt was a useful predictor of falls in older
people (Edward et al. 2002). So reduction in blood pressure
may predipose some elderly people to symptomatic hypotension
leading to syncope, fall and fractures. These symptoms
can easily be overlooked in the elderly, and they can
be attributed to ageing, without expecting a possible
decline in the role of the autonomic nervous system
in the cardiovascular reflexes which were described
previously in the elderly.
Autonomic cardiovascular dysfunctions, particularly
orthostatic hypotension should be considered seriously
in all elderly people, particularly those at risk, for
example, those with supine hypertension or those using
vasodilator drugs. Elderly people should be advised
to change their posture slowly after lying in bed or
sitting in a chair for a long time. They should also
be advised to take small frequent meals to reduce postprandial
hypotension. Head-up tilt at night to as much as can
be tolerated, can to some extent down regulate cerebral
blood flow, and it can also prevent nocturnal diuresis.
The floor of the house should be made in such way to
reduce the possibility of fall. Hot bath or bathing
when alone at home should be avoided by the elderly.
Blood pressure should be measured routinely in the supine
and standing positions for all elderly people to check
for possibility of postural hypotension. These preventive
measures may reduce the risk of the clinical outcome
of postural hypotension, like dizziness, falls and fractures
which may lead to prolonged
rehabilitation, and increase morbidity and mortality
in the elderly.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The investigator is very
grateful to King Abdul-Aziz City for Science and Technology
for their generous support. I am also thankful for the
Department of Physiology, College of Medicine, King
Saud University, where the research took place. My thanks
are also extended to all volunteers who participated
in this study, and to the technicians, and the Statistician,
who helped me during the research.
REFERENCES
1. Mancia G, Gleroux J,
Daffonchio A: Reflex control of circulation in the elderly.
Cardiovas Drugs Ther 1990; 4:1223-1228.
2. Consensus statement on the
definition of orthostatic hypotension, pure autonomic
failure, and multiple system atrophy. The consensus
committee of the American Autonomic Society and the
American Academy of Neurology. 1996;46:1470.
3. Collins KJ, Sacco P, Easton
JC, Abdel-Rahman TA. Cold pressor and trigeminal cardiovascular
reflexes in old age. In Mercer JBed. Thermal physiology.
Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers BV, 1989: 587-92.
4. Eckberg DL, Sleight P: Human
Baroreflexes in health and disease pp 153-215. Oxford
University Press, Oxford, 1992.
5. Collins KJ, Abdel-Rahman
TA, Goodwin J, Mc Tiffin L: Circadian body temperatures
and the effects of a cold stress in elderly and young
subjects. Age and ageing 1995;24:485-489.
6. Collins KJ, Abdel-Rahman
TA, Easton JC et al: Effect of facial cooling on elderly
and young subjects: Interactions with breath-holding
and lower body negative pressure. Clin Sci 1996;70:485-472.
7. Abdel-Rahman TA, Collin KJ,
Cowen T, Rustin M: Immunohistochemical, morphological
and functional changes in the peripheral sudomotor neuro-effector
system in elderly people. J Aut Nerv Syst 1992; 37:187-198.
8. Abdel-Rahman TA, Cowen T:
Neurodegeneration in sweat glands and skin of aged rats.
J Aut Nerv Syst 1993;46:55-63.
9. Madder SL, Josephson KR,
Rubenstein LZ. Low prevalence of postural hypotension
among community-dwelling elderly. JAMA 1987;258:1511-4
10. Ooi WL, Barret S, Hossian
M, Kelly-Gagnon M, Lipsitz LA. Patterns of orthostatic
blood pressure change and their clinical correlates
in a frail, elderly population. JAMA 1997;277:1299-304.
11. Petersen ME, Williams TR,
Gordon C, Chamberlain- Webber R, Sutton R. The normal
response to prolonged passive head up tilt testing.
Heart 2000;84:509-14.
12. Sumiyoshi M, Mineda Y, Kojima
S, Suwa S, Nakata Y. Poor reproducibility of false-positive
tilt testing results in healthy volunteers. Jpn Heart
J 1999;40:71-8.
13. Rutan GH, Hermanson B, Bild
DE, Kittner SJ, LaBaw F, Tell GS. Orthostatic hypotension
in older adults. The Cardiovascular Health Study. CHS
Collaborative Research Group. Hypertension 1992;19:508-19.
14. Eigenbrodt ML, Rose KM,
Couper DJ, Arnett DK, Smith R, Jones D. Orthostatic
hypotension as a risk factor for stroke: the atherosclerosis
risk in communities (ARIC) study, 1987-1996. Stroke
2000;31:2307-13.
15. Edward Heitterachi, Stephen
R. Lord, Phillip MeyerKort, lan Mc Closkey and Richard
FitzPatrick. Blood pressure changes on upright tilting
predict falls in older people. Age and aging 2002; 31:181-186.
16. Ziegler MG, Postural hypotension.
Ann Rev Med 1980;31:239-245.
17. Lye M, Vargas E, Faragher
EB et al: Haemodynamic and neurohumoral responses in
elderly patients with postural hypotension. Eur J Clin
Invest 1990;20:90-96.
18. Polinsky RJ. Clinical autonomic
neuropharmacolgy. Neurol Clin 1990;8:77-92.
19. Lipsitz LA. Orthostatic
hypotension in the elderly. N Engl J Med 1989; 321:1952-7.
20. Weiling W. VanLieshout JJ.
Maintenance of postural normotension in human. In: Low
PA. Clinical autonomic disorders: evaluation and management
Boston: Little, Brown, 1993:69-77.
21. Ferrari AU, Grassi G, Mancia
G: alteration in reflex control of circulation associated
with ageing. pp. 39-50. In Anvery A, staesson J (eds):
Handbook of hypertension. Vol.12. Elsevier Science Publishing.
Amsterdam, 1989.
22. Macrae AD, Bulpitt CJ: assessment
of postural hypotension in elderly patients. Age ageing
1989; 18: 110-112.
23. Mo R, Omvik P, Lund-Johansen
P: the Bergen blood pressure study: estimated prevalence
of postural hypotension is influenced by the alerting
reaction to blood pressure measurement. Hum Hypertens
1994; 8: 171-176.
24. Korkushko OU, Shatilo VB.
Plachinda Y. Shatilo TV: Autonomic control of cardiac
chronotropic function in man as a function of age: assessment
by power spectral analysis of heart rate variability.
J Aut Nerv Syst 1991;32:191-198.
25. Hajduczok G, Chapleau MW,
Jonson SL, Abboud FM: Increase in sympathetic activity
with age. 1 role of impairment
of arterial baroreflexes. Am J Physiol 1991;260 H1113-H1120.
|