|
ABSTRACT
The present study
was conducted on 70 patients undergoing intestinal
stoma creation, in the Department of General Surgery,
Jawaharlal Nehru Medical College, Aligarh Muslim
University, Aligarh, India. The aim of the present
study was to assess and quantify the serum electrolyte
changes in patients following ileostomy or colostomy,
to identify and estimate need of electrolyte replacement
and to develop a regime for electrolyte supplementation,
based on the findings of this study, if indicated.
Serum electrolytes
namely serum sodium, serum potassium, serum calcium,
serum magnesium and serum chloride were estimated
in patients who underwent stoma creation, in the
postoperative period, on postoperative day 1,
day 3 and day 5. For the purpose of study and
comparisons, the intestinal stoma patients were
further divided into groups based on (1) type
of stoma (ileostomy or colostomy), (2) those with
ileal segmental resection along with ileostomy
and (3) amount of daily stoma output. All the
patients received the same intravenous fluid and
electrolytes regime until the 3rd postoperative
day. However, no patient was allowed to go into
a fluid deficit.
Key words: Serum
electrolytes, sodium, potassium, calcium, magnesium,
chloride, t-test, ileostomy, colostomy postoperatively.
|
INTRODUCTION
Chief electrolytes in the human
body are Sodium, Potassium, Calcium, Magnesium, Chloride,
Bicarbonate, etc. (Na+, K+, Ca2+, Mg2-, Cl-, HCO3-).
The maintenance of optimal function of body physiology
depends on proper concentration or proportion of these
electrolytes within a narrow normal range. Derangement
i.e. excess or depletion of electrolytes in the body
leads to derangement of physiological function.
Maintaining fluid and electrolyte
balance requires understanding of normal intake and
output of major electrolytes required for body economy,
including the consideration of abnormal losses of fluids
(Intestinal stomas, fistulas, gastric aspiration, drains
etc.), their electrolyte content and the deficiencies
acquired thereby. An intestinal stoma is an opening
of intestinal tract on to the abdominal wall. It mainly
functions to divert the faeces and flatus to the exterior.
It may be an ileostomy or colostomy depending on the
exteriorisation of either ileum or colon respectively.
In rare instances, proximal small bowel can be taken
out as a jejunostomy.
A stoma may be a low volume
stoma, in which daily volume is around 500 ml or a high
volume stoma, in which daily volume is one litre or
more (Hill et al, 1974). Patients with stoma output
less than one litre daily are seldom troubled. On the
other hand patients with high output stomas are prone
to salt and water depletion. If a significant amount
of ileum is resected at the time of an ileostomy operation,
output from the resulting ileostomy tends to be unusually
profuse (Nuguid et al, 1961, Hill et al, 1974).
The omission of an intestinal
stoma may result in morbidity or even mortality - this
must be weighed against the physical, metabolic and
psychological complications of an ileostomy or colostomy.
One of the biochemical parameters is the study of serum
electrolytes, namely serum sodium, serum potassium,
serum calcium, serum magnesium and serum chloride, in
surgical patients undergoing intestinal stoma creation,
either ileostomy or colostomy postoperatively.
AIMS
AND OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
(1) To assess and quantify the serum electrolyte changes
in patients following ileostomy/ colostomy.
(2) To identify and estimate need for electrolyte replacement.
(3) To develop a regime for electrolyte supplementation
based on the findings of this study, if indicated.
This study was carried out in the postoperative period
of surgical patients who underwent stoma creation and
who were maintained on intra-venous fluid and electrolyte
regime followed in this hospital (dextrose and ringer
lactate) until the 3rd postoperative day, and blood
transfusion done wherever indicated. However no patient
was allowed to go into a fluid deficit.
MATERIALS
AND METHODS
This study was conducted on
70 surgical cases admitted in the Department of General
Surgery, J.N. Medical College, A.M.U., Aligarh and who
went for the creation of intestinal stomas. Clinical
examination and investigations i.e. serum sodium, serum
potassium, serum calcium, serum chloride and serum magnesium,
and quantity of stoma output, were done postoperatively
at 24 hrs (1st day), 96 hrs (3rd day) and 120 hrs (5th
day). Patients who were below 12 years of age were not
included in this study.
Intestinal Stoma Output Quantity in ml
Serum Values: Electrolytes
Serum Sodium: Normal value of serum sodium taken was
135-145 mEq/L or 135- 145 mmol/L
Serum Potassium: Normal values of serum potassium was
taken between 3.5-5.0 mEq/L or 3.5-5.0 mmol/L
Serum Calcium: Normal value
of serum calcium was 2.1-2.6 mmol/L (8.5-10.5 mg/dL)
(conversion factor 0.25) (Young DS, 1987). [Calcium:
mmol/L=mEq/Lx0.5=mg/dlx0.25]
Serum Magnesium: Normal value of serum magnesium was
taken as 0.75-1.25 mmol/L or 1.8-3.0 mg/dL or 1.4-2.2
mEq/L (Young DS, 1987). [Magnesium: mmol/L =mEq/Lx0.5=mg/dLx0.41]
Serum Chloride: Normal value of serum chloride was taken
as 98-107 mmol/L (mEq/L) (Young DS, 1987).
Estimation of Serum Electrolytes
(sodium, potassium, magnesium, calcium and chloride)
was done.
STATISTICAL
ANALYSIS
Processing of data: All the
observations have been statistically analyzed. The standard
deviation has been calculated using the formula:

The Students -test of significance is applied to test
the significance of difference of values between different
samples the value of 't' was calculated by the
following formula:

where,
= Mean of first sample
= Mean of second sample
S1 = Standard deviation of first sample
S2 = Standard deviation of second sample
n1= Number of cases in first sample
n2 = Number of cases in second sample
The value of 't' and P are seen from the table.
The value is less than 0.05 and is considered to be
significant.
OBSERVATIONS
The estimation of serum electrolytes, namely serum sodium
serum potassium, serum calcium, serum magnesium and
serum chloride were done postoperatively at 24 hours
(1st postoperative day), 72 hours (3rd postoperative
day) and 120 hours (5th postoperative day). During the
postoperative study period, two patients expired, one
on the 4th and the other on the 5th postoperative day,
respectively. All of the patients in this study had
their stoma created on operation for emergency conditions.
Table 1: Case Distribution
according to Age and Sex

Table 1 reveals that the
maximum number of patients were in the 13-25 years of
age group i.e. 28 (16 males and 12 female) and the youngest
patient was 13 years old and the oldest was 80 years
old. The mean age of the patients was 33.14 years. (Males
35.36 years and females 29.82 years).
Table 2: Case
distribution according to operative procedure and sex
Table 2 depicts that out of
the total 70 patients, 58 patients underwent ileostomy
(33 males, 25 females), and out of these 16 patients
underwent resection of small bowel in addition to ileostomy
(10 males and 6 females). Twelve patients had colostomy
(9 males and 3 females) as the operative procedure.
Patient having stoma without additional resection of
small intestine were 54 (colostomy patients +patients
having ileostomy with no resection of small bowel) (32
males and 22 females).
Table
3: Case distribution according to diagnosis

From Table 3 the majority of
the patients who underwent stoma creation were of perforation
peritonitis 43 (61.6%) patients following typhoid, tubercular
or non-specific enteritis. Twenty patients (28.6%) presented
with intestinal obstruction, out of these 7 cases had
malignancy. Ten cases in addition to obstruction had
associated peritonitis (6 cases of adhesion obstruction,
2 of malignancy and one each of caecal and sigmoid volvulus).
The remaining 7 cases had stoma creation due to gun
shot abdomen (3), septic abortion (2) and rectal and
perineal injury (2)
Table
4: Postoperative stoma output (in ml)

From Table 4, the average daily
quantity of stoma output in all patients on the 3rd
postoperative day was 441.4 ml and on the 5th postoperative
day was 641.1 ml. Stoma output on the first postoperative
day was not taken into consideration as most of the
stomas were not functioning at that time.
The average daily stoma output
in patients having stoma with no resection of small
bowel was 416.7 ml and 586.8 ml on the 3rd and 5th postoperative
days respectively and in patients having ileostomy with
resection of small bowel was 525 ml on the 3rd postoperative
day and 833.3 ml on the 5th postoperative day.
The average daily stoma output
in patients having ileostomy with no resection of small
bowel was 476.2 ml on the 3rd day postoperative and
670.7 ml on the 5th postoperative day.
The average daily stoma output
in all patients having ileostomy was 489.6 ml on the
3rd postoperative day and 714.3 ml on the 5th postoperative
and in patients having colostomy was 208.3 ml on the
3rd postoperative 300 ml on the 5th postoperative day.
Quantity of stoma output between
ileostomy and colostomy patients showed a highly significant
lower amount in colostomy patients on both the 3rd and
5th postoperative days (p<0.001).
Patients who underwent additional
intestinal resection had a significantly higher stoma
output. Stoma output of patients without any resection
of small intestine showed a significant lower amount
on the 3rd postoperative day (p<0.05) and a highly
significant lower amount on the 5th postoperative day
(p<0.001).
Table
5: Distribution according to stoma output and
procedure done

Res. S.I =
Resection of small intestine.
On the 3rd postoperative day,
out of 42 patients of ileostomy with no resection of
small bowel 22 (52.4%) had stoma output less than 500
ml and rest 20 (47.6%) had stoma output between 500-1000
ml with a mean of 476.2±190.9 ml and on the 5th
postoperative day out of 41 patients 6 (14.6%) had stoma
output less than 500 ml, 33 (80.5%) between 500-1000
ml and 2 (4.9%) more than 1000 ml with a mean output
of 670.7±161.2 ml (Tables -4 & 5).
In 16 patients having ileostomy
with resection of small bowel, 5 (31.2%) had stoma output
less than 500 ml and 11 (68.8%) had stoma output between
500-1000 ml on the 3rd postoperative day with a mean
of 525±126.2 ml. On the 5th postoperative day
out of 15 patients of ileostomy with resection of small
bowel 10 (66.7%) had stoma between 500-1000 ml and 5
(33.3%) had stoma output more than 1000 ml with a mean
of 833.3±194.6 ml (Tables -4 & 5).
In 54 patients of stoma with
no resection 34 (63%) had stoma output <500 ml and
the rest 20 (37%) had stoma output between 500-1000
ml on the 3rd postoperative day. On the 5th postoperative
day, of the 53 patients, 18 (34%) had stoma output <500
ml, 33 (62.5%) had stoma output between 500-1000 ml,
and 2 (3.5%) had stoma output >1000 ml.
In a total 12 patients of colostomy,
the stoma output was less than 500 ml on both the 3rd
and 5th postoperative days with a mean of 208.3±90.9
ml on the 3rd and 300±95.7 ml on the 5th postoperative
day. (Tables -4 & 5).
Table
6: Various groups of intestinal stoma patients
(n=no. of patients)

*2 patients expired, 1 on the 4th day
and the other on the 5th post-op. day.
Group (1): All stoma patients
containing all ileostomy and colostomy patients (n=70).
Group (2): All ileostomy patients (n=58).
Group (3): Ileostomy patients who underwent additional
resection of small bowel (n=16).
Group (4): Stoma (Ileostomy+Colostomy) patients having
no resection of small bowel (n=54).
Group (5): All colostomy patients (n=12)
Group (6): Patients having stoma output ³1000 ml
on postoperative day 5 (n=7).
SERUM
ELECTROLYTES
(i) Serum Sodium:
Table
7: Comparison of serum sodium (in mmol/L) in
various groups of intestinal stoma patients (mean±S.D)

(1) In the group having all
stoma patients, when postoperative day 1 reading was
compared to postoperative day 3 and day 5 readings,
a significant lower reading was observed on day 3 (p<0.05)
and day 5 (p<0.001). When postoperative day 3 reading
was compared with postoperative day 5 reading a significant
lower reading was observed on postoperative day 5(p<0.01).
[A:B=S, A:C=S, B:C=S; (S=significant, NS=not significant)].
(2) In the group having all
ileostomy patients, when postoperative day 1 reading
was compared to postoperative day 3 and day 5 readings,
a significant lower reading was observed on postoperative
day 3 (p<0.05) and day 5 (p<0.001). When postoperative
day 3 reading was compared with postoperative day 5
reading a significant lower reading was observed on
postoperative day 5(p<0.01). [A:B=S, A:C=S, B:C=S].
(3) In the group having ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, when postoperative
day 1 reading was compared to postoperative day 3 and
day 5 readings, a significant lower value was observed
on postoperative day 3 (p<0.05) and day 5 (p<0.001).
When postoperative day 3 reading was compared with postoperative
day 5 reading a significant lower value was observed
on day 5 (p<0.01). [A:B=S, A:C=S, B:C=S].
(4) In the group having stoma
with no resection of small intestine no statistically
significant change (p>0.05) was observed when postoperative
day 1 and day 3 readings were compared. However, a statistically
significant lower reading was observed on postoperative
day 5 (p<0.05). Changes in serum sodium level between
postoperative day 3 and day 5, though lower on postoperative
day 5, were not statistically significant. [A:B=NS,
A:C=S, B:C=NS].
(5) In the group having colostomy,
no significant change (p>0.05) was observed when
postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 readings were compared
to each other. [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(6) In the group having daily
stoma output ³1000 ml (on 5th day), no significant
change (p>0.05) was noted when postoperative day
1 reading was compared to postoperative day 3 reading.
A statistically significant lower value was observed
on postoperative day 5 when postoperative day 1 and
day 3 readings were compared to the postoperative day
5 reading (p<0.05). [A:B=NS, A:C=S, B:C=S].
In comparison of group (2) ileostomy
and group (5) colostomy patients, no significant change
(p>0.05) was observed when postoperative day 1 readings
were compared. When postoperative day 3 and day 5 readings
were compared between groups (2) and (5), the readings
in the ileostomy group were found to be significantly
lower than in the colostomy group (p<0.001). [A:A=NS,
B:B=S, C:C=S].
In comparison of group (3) ileostomy
with resection of small intestine and group (4) stoma
with no resection of small intestine, no significant
change (p>0.05) was observed when postoperative day
1 readings were compared. When postoperative day 3 and
day 5 readings were compared between these groups (3
and 4), the reading in group (3) ileostomy with resection
of small intestine, were found to be significantly lower
than in group (4) (p<0.05). [A:A=NS, B:B=S, C:C=S].
Except for the patients of group
(3) ileostomy with resection of ileal segment and (6)
stoma patients with output ³1000 ml/day who on
the 5th day had a mean serum sodium level below 135
mmol/m on postoperative day 5, all other groups of stoma
had mean serum sodium levels in normal range in the
postoperative period.
The value of serum sodium ranged
from 134-143 mmol/L on postoperative day 1, 132-145
mmol/L on postoperative day 3 and 132-144 mmol/L on
postoperative day 5.
Three out of 70 patients on postoperative day 1 and
five out of 70 patients on postoperative day 3 had serum
sodium values less than 135 mmol/L. On postoperative
day 5, 9 out of 68 patients had serum sodium values
less than 135 mmol/L. The rest of the patients had values
in the normal range of 135-145 mmol/L.
(ii) Serum Potassium:
Table 8: Comparison
of serum potassium (in mmol/L) in various groups of
intestinal stoma patients (mean±S.D)

(1) In the group having all
stoma patients, when postoperative day 1 reading was
compared with postoperative day 3 and day 5 reading,
a significant lower value was observed, on postoperative
day 3 (p<0.05) and day 5(p<0.001). When postoperative
day 3 reading was compared with postoperative day 5
reading, there was no significant change (p>0.05)
observed. [A:B=S, A:C=S, B:C=NS].
(2) In the group having all
ileostomy patients, when postoperative day 1 reading
was compared with postoperative day 5 reading, a significant
lower value (p<0.05) was observed on postoperative
day 5. When postoperative day 3 reading was compared
with postoperative day 1 and day 5 readings, no significant
change was observed (p>0.05). [A:B=NS, A:C=S, B:C=NS].
(3) In the group having ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, when postoperative
day 1, reading was compared to postoperative day 3 and
day 5 readings, a significant lower value (p<0.05)
was observed on postoperative day 3 and day 5. When
postoperative day 3 reading was compared with postoperative
5 day reading, no significant change (p>0.05) was
observed. [A:B=S, A:C=S, B:C=NS].
(4) In the group having stoma
with no resection of small intestine, when postoperative
day 1 reading was compared to postoperative day 3 and
day 5 readings, postoperative day 3 (p<0.05) and
day 5 (p<0.001) readings were found to be significantly
lower than day 1. No significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 3 reading was compared
to postoperative day 5 reading. [A:B=S, A:C=S, B:C=NS].
(5) In the group having colostomy,
no significant change (p>0.05) was observed when
postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 readings were compared
to each other. [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(6) In the group having daily
stoma output³1000 ml on the 5th postoperative day,
when postoperative day 1 reading was compared to postoperative
day 5, postoperative day 5 reading was observed to be
significantly lower (p<0.05). No significant change
(p>0.05) was observed when postoperative day 3 reading
was compared to postoperative day 1 and day 5 readings.
[A:B=NS, A:C=S, B:C=NS].
In comparison of group (2) ileostomy
and group (5) colostomy, no significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 1, day 3 and day
5 readings were compared between these groups. [A:A=NS,
B:B=NS, C:C=NS].
In comparison of group (3) ileostomy
with resection of small intestine and group (4) stoma
without resection of small intestine no significant
change (p>0.05) was observed when postoperative day
1, day 3 and day 5 readings were compared between these
groups. [A:A=NS, B:B=NS, C:C=NS].
The mean values of serum potassium
remained within the normal range in the postoperative
period in all groups.
The values of serum potassium
ranged from 3.4-5.0 mmol/L on postoperative day 1, 3.3-5.2
mmol/L on postoperative day 3 and 3.2-5.0 mmol/L on
postoperative day 5.
Two out of 70 stoma patients
on postoperative day 1, and four out of 70 patients
on postoperative day 3 had serum potassium values less
than 3.5 mmol/L. One patient on postoperative day 3
had serum potassium values more than 5.0 mmol/L. Five
out of 68 patients on postoperative 5 had serum potassium
values less than 3.5 mmol/L. The rest of the patients
had serum potassium values in the normal range of 3.5-5.0
mmol/L.
(iii) Serum Calcium:
Table
9: Comparison of serum calcium (in mmol/L) in
various groups of intestinal stoma patients (mean±S.D)

No significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 1, day 2 and day
3 readings were compared within the groups in the following
groups.
(1) Group having all stoma patients [A:B=NS, A:C=NS,
B:C=NS].
(2) Group having all ileostomy patients [A:B=NS, A:C=NS,
B:C=NS].
(3) Group having ileostomy with resection of small intestine
[A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(4) Group having stoma patients with no resection of
small intestine [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(5) Group having all colostomy patients [A:B=NS, A:C=NS,
B:C=NS].
(6) Group having patient with stoma output ³1000
ml on the 5th postoperative day, [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
In comparison of postoperative
day 1, day 3 and day 5 readings between group (2) ileostomy
and group (5) colostomy, no significant change was observed
(p>0.05). [A:A=NS, B:B=NS, C:C=NS].
In comparison of group (3) ileostomy
with resection of small intestine and group (4) stoma
with no resection of small intestine, no significant
change was observed (p>0.05) [A:A=NS, B:B=NS, C:C=NS].
The mean values of serum calcium
remained within the normal range in the postoperative
period in all groups.
The values of serum calcium
ranged from 2.12-2.58 mmol/L on postoperative day 1,
1.94-2.57 mmol/L on day 3 and 1.91-2.56 mmol/L on postoperative
day 5.
Out of 70 patients, 3 patients developed carpopedal
spasm and tetany. (2 on the 4th day and 1 on the 3rd
postoperative day). Two of these three patients had
serum calcium values less than 2.1 mmol/L on the 3rd
and 5th postoperative days. The rest of the patients
had serum calcium values to a normal range of 2.1-2.6
mmol/L.
(iv) Serum Magnesium:
Table
10: Comparison of serum magnesium (in mmol/L)
in various groups of intestinal stoma patients (mean±S.D)

No significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 1, day 3 and day
5 readings were compared within the groups in the following
groups:
(1) Group having all stoma patients [A:B=NS, A:C=NS,
B:C=NS].
(2) Group having all ileostomy patients [A:B=NS, A:C=NS,
B:C=NS].
(3) Group having ileostomy with resection of small intestine
[A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(4) Group having stoma patients with no resection of
small intestine [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(5) Group having all ileostomy patients [A:B=NS, A:C=NS,
B:C=NS].
(6) Group having patients with stoma output ³1000
ml on the 5th postoperative day [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
No significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 1, day 3 and day
5 readings were compared between the following groups:
[A:A=NS, B:B=NS, C:C=NS].
- Group (2) ileostomy and group (5) colostomy and.
- Group (3) ileostomy with resection of small intestine
and group (4) stoma with no resection of small intestine.
The mean values of serum magnesium
remained within the normal range in the postoperative
period in all groups. The values of serum magnesium
ranged from 0.75-1.23 mmol/L on postoperative day 1,
0.75-1.24 mmol/L on day 3 and 0.75-1.26 mmol/L on day
5. In one patient serum magnesium value was more than
1.25 mmol/L on postoperative day 5. The rest of the
patients had serum magnesium value in normal range of
0.75-1.25 mmol/L.
(v) Serum Chloride:
Table
11: Comparison of serum chloride (in mmol/L)
in various groups of intestinal stoma patients (mean±S.D)

No significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 1, day 3 and day
5 readings were compared within the groups in the following
groups: [A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=NS].
(1) Group having all stoma patients.
(4) Group having stoma patients with no resection of
small intestine.
(5) Group having colostomy patients.
(6) Group having patients with stoma output ³1000
ml on the 5th postoperative day.
In group (3) having all ileostomy
patients, no significant change (p>0.05) was observed
when postoperative day 1 reading was compared to postoperative
day 3 and day 5 readings. When postoperative day 3 and
day 5 readings were compared, the postoperative day
5 reading was found to be significantly lower (p<0.05).
[A:B=NS, A:C=NS, B:C=S].
In group (3) having ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, no significant change
(p>0.05) was observed when the postoperative day
1 reading was compared to the postoperative day 3 reading.
Postoperative day 5 reading was found to be significantly
lower (p<0.05) when it was compared to postoperative
day 1 and 3 readings. [A:B=NS, A:C=S, B:C=S].
In comparison of group (2) ileostomy
and group (5) colostomy postoperative day 3 and day
5 readings were found to be significantly lower (p<0.05)
in the ileostomy group, but no significant change (p>0.05)
was observed when postoperative day 1 reading was compared
between these groups. [A:A=NS, B:B=S, C:C=S].
In comparison of group (3) ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, and group (4) stoma
with no resection of small intestine, postoperative
day 1, day 3 and day 5 readings were found to be significantly
lower (p<0.05) in group (3) having ileostomy with
resection of small intestine. [A:A=S, B:B=S, C:C=S].
The mean values of serum chloride
remained within the normal range in the postoperative
period in all groups.
The value of serum chloride
ranged from 98-107 mmol/L on postoperative day 1, 97-107
mmol/L on day 3 and 97-107 mmol/L on day 5. Two patients
had serum chloride values less than 98 mmol/L, one on
day 3 and the other on day 5. The rest of the patients
had serum chloride values in the normal range of 98-107
mmol/L.
DISCUSSION
The age of the patients in the
study was in the range of 13-80 years, with a mean of
33.14 years. Most of the patients in our study (61.5%)
were in the 13-35 year age group. the majority of the
patients (>90%) underwent stoma creation for perforation
peritonitis (Enteric, Tubercular and other causes) (61.6%)
and intestinal obstruction (28.6%). There were no cases
of Crohn's and ulcerative colitis or diverticulitis.
It is in contrast to the study
of G. Swaninger et al 1991, where most of the patients
were of Crohn's disease (mean age 41 years) and ulcerative
colitis (mean age 38 years) who were operated for ileostomy.
In the study of Thomas L.B et
al, 2003, most patients were elderly (above 70 years)
and ostomy was created for cancer (33.0%), IBD (21.9%),
diverticulitis (14.9%) and only 2.3% for perforation
peritonitis. In our study, there were only 7 cases (10%)
of malignancy and 43 (61.6%) cases were of the perforation
peritonitis, who underwent stoma creation.
Quantity of Daily stoma output
in postoperative period:
In the previous studies the volume of daily ileostomy
output was reported in the range of 200-500 ml (Welch
et al 1936; Brooke 1957; Smiddy et al 1960; Kramer et
al, 1962; Kanaghinis et al, 1963). Low volume ileostomy
was defined as daily output around 500 ml and high volume
ileostomy as a daily volume of a litre or more, by Hill
et al 1974, 1975c.
In our study the average stoma
volume in ileostomy patients was 489.6(±176.8)
ml on the 3rd day and 714.3(±182.9) ml on the
5th postoperative day.
The ileostomy output tended
to be unusually profuse if additional ileal resection
had to be performed (Nuguid et al, 1961; Hill et al,
1974, 1975). In our study the ileostomy patients in
which resection of ileum was done, the mean output on
the 3rd postoperative day was 525(±126.2) ml
and on the 5th day was 833.3(±194.6) ml and was
significantly higher than patients having stomas with
no resection of the ileum (p<0.05).
New ileostomy may produce a
diarrhoea of 1-2 litre/day as reported by Wright et
al, 1973. In this study, 7 (10%) of ileostomy patients
had ³1000 ml/day of stoma output on 5th postoperative
day; 5 of these 7 patients had ileostomy with ileal
resection. The output from colostomy was significant
lower than ileostomy and the metabolic changes were
mostly confined to the ileostomy patients. Similar results
were reported by P.G. Reasbeck et al (1989).
SERUM SODIUM:
The present study revealed a significant decrease in
serum sodium concentration postoperatively in patients
who underwent stoma creation. Ileostomy patients had
significantly lower serum sodium levels compared to
colostomy patients on the 3rd and 5th postoperative
days (p<0.001).
Ileostomy patients having resection
of small intestine had significantly lower serum sodium
levels compared to stoma patients with no resection
of small bowel on the 3rd and 5th postoperative days
(p<0.05). No significant difference was found on
postoperative day 1.
The mean value of serum sodium
on postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 remained within
the normal range in all groups of stoma patients except
the group having ileostomy with resection of small intestine,
and the group of patients having stoma output ³1
litre on postoperative day 5, in which mean serum sodium
level decreased below normal on postoperative day 5.
In the group having all stoma
patients, there was a decrease in the mean serum sodium
level from postoperative day 1 to day 5. The differences
between postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 were statistically
significant (p<0.05).
In the group having all ileostomy
patients, there was a decrease in mean serum sodium
levels from postoperative day 1 to day 5 which was found
to be statistically significant (p<0.05).
In the group having ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, there was a decrease
in mean serum sodium levels from postoperative day 1
to day 5 reaching below normal range on postoperative
day 5 (134.30±1.1 mmol/L). The difference between
postoperative day 1 and day 3 was significant and the
difference between postoperative day 5 and postoperative
day 3(p<0.01) and day 1 was highly significant (p<0.001).
In the group having stoma with
no resection of the small bowel, postoperative day 5
values of serum sodium were significantly lower than
day 1 values (p<0.05), but no significant difference
was found between comparison of other postoperative
values.
In the group having colostomy,
no significant difference was found in serum sodium
values in the postoperative period.
In the group having stoma output
³1000 ml/day on the 5th postoperative day, there
was a significantly lower value of mean serum sodium
on the 5th postoperative day as compared to postoperative
day 1 and day 3. The mean serum sodium value was lower
than the normal range on the 5th postoperative day (133.6±1
mmol/L).
The above findings correspond
to the works of Hill G-L et al, 1974, Gallagher et al,
1962, Clarke et al, 1967, 1969 who also observed decrease
in serum levels in the postoperative period in patients
with ileostomy. Nuguid et al, 1961, Wright et al, 1973,
Hill et al, 1974, 1975, also observed that resection
of ileum with ileostomy increases stoma output and electrolyte
losses. P.G. Reasbeck et al, 1989, also observed that
metabolic complications are mostly confined to ileostomy
patients.
SERUM POTASSIUM:
In our study, no significant change was observed when
postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 serum potassium
values were compared between ileostomy and colostomy
patients and between patients having ileostomy with
resection of ileum and stoma patients with no resection
of ileum.
The mean values of serum potassium
of postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 remained within
the normal range in all groups of stoma patients.
In all the groups of stoma patients,
the value of serum potassium decreased slightly from
postoperative day 1 to day 5 but remained within the
normal range.
Significantly lower serum potassium
values of postoperative day 3 and day 5 were observed
compared to postoperative day 1 in the groups of all
stoma patients, ileostomy patients with resection of
small intestine and ileostomy patients with no resection
of small bowel (p<0.05). No significant change was
observed between postoperative day 3 and day 5 values.
In the groups having all ileostomy
patients and patients with stoma output more ³1000
ml on the 5th day, the postoperative day 5 value of
serum potassium was found to be significantly lower
than the day 1 value (p<0.05). No significant change
was found in the postoperative period in the colostomy
patients.
This is in agreement with the
results documented by various authors L.O Nilsson et
al, 1982, Turnberg L.A et al, 1978, J.C. Goligher 1975,
who observed a slight decrease in serum potassium levels
in ileostomy patients but found no signs of potassium
depletion in patients with ileostomy.
However, some other authors
have observed an increase in serum potassium level in
patients with ileostomy (N.D Gallagher et al, 1962,
Swaniger et al, 1991). No such increase was noted in
this study.
SERUM CALCIUM:
No significant change was observed when postoperative
day 1, day 3 and day 5 serum calcium values were compared
between ileostomy and colostomy patients groups and
between patients having ileostomy with resection of
ileum and patients having stoma with no resection of
ileum.
The mean values of serum calcium
on postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 remained within
the normal range in all groups of stoma patients.
No significant change was observed when the postoperative
day 1, day 3 and day 5 serum calcium values were compared
with each other within the various intestinal stomas
groups.
The above findings are similar
to work done by Daly, DW 1968; Singer et al, 1973; K.J.
Kennedy, Compston et al, 1983 who studied changes in
serum levels of calcium in ileostomists and found no
significant changes.
During this study three patients
of ileostomy developed carpopedal spasm and tetany,
but only two had hypocalcemia and the third had normal
serum calcium value. Their mean stoma output was 800
ml/day but none had undergone additional resection and
this aberration remained unexplained although some workers
noticed this rare complication of decreased serum calcium
level in high output stomas. (Healton et al, 1967; Daly
DW, 1968; Hill GL et al, 1976; Prasad ML et al, 1984).
SERUM MAGNESIUM:
In this study, no significant change was observed when
postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 serum magnesium
values were compared between ileostomy and colostomy
patients groups and between patients having ileostomy
with resection of ileum and patients having stoma with
no resection of ileum.
The mean serum magnesium values
on postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 remained within
the normal range in all groups of stoma patients.
No significant change was observed
when the postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5 serum
magnesium values were compared with each other within
the various intestinal stomas groups.
The above findings are similar
to work done by H.J. Kennedy, Compston et al, 1983;
Hill GL et al, 1976; who studied serum magnesium levels
in patients with ileostomy and found no significant
changes although magnesium depletion occasionally is
seen in patients with high volume ileostomies (Heaton
et al, 1967; Hill GL et al, 1976; Prasad ML, 1984).
SERUM CHLORIDE:
In our study, significantly lower values of serum chloride
on postoperative day 3 and day 5 were found in ileostomy
patients groups compared to the colostomy group (p<0.05).
Also, significantly lower serum
chloride levels on postoperative day 1, day 3 and day
5 were found in patients having ileostomy with resection
of ileum as compared to patients having stoma with no
resection of ileum (p<0.05).
The mean serum chloride values
of all stoma groups remained within the normal range
on postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5.
No significant changes were
found when the postoperative day 1, day 3 and day 5
serum chloride values were compared with each other
within the groups of all stoma patients, stoma patients
with no resection of small intestine, colostomy patients
and patients with stoma output more than 1 litre on
the 5th postoperative day.
In the group having all ileostomy
patients, postoperative day 5 serum chloride values
were found to be significantly lower than postoperative
day 3 values (p<0.05).
In the group having ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, postoperative day
5 serum chloride value was found to be significantly
lower than postoperative day 1 and day 3 values (p<0.05).
These above findings are similar
to the work done by Hill G.L, 1967, Clarke et al, 1967,
Kramer P, 1966, Pearl RK, Prasad ML et al, 1984, who
reported decreased sodium and chloride levels in patients
following ileostomy.
Serum electrolytes and their
relationship to quantity of stoma output, and resection
of small intestine:
The average quantity of postoperative stoma output in
patients with ileostomy was significantly higher than
the colostomy patients (p<0.05). Significantly lower
levels of serum sodium and serum chloride were found
on postoperative day 3 and day 5 in patients with ileostomy
compared to colostomy patients (p<0.05). In addition,
in the ileostomy group, a significant decrease in levels
of serum sodium, serum potassium and chloride occurred
in the postoperative period but usually remained within
the normal range.
The average quantity of postoperative
stoma output was significantly higher in patients having
ileostomy with resection of small intestine, compared
to stoma patients with no resection of small intestine
(p<0.05). Significantly lower levels of serum sodium
and chloride were observed postoperatively in patients
having ileostomy with resection of small intestine compared
to stoma patients with no resection of small intestine
(p<0.05). In addition, in the group having ileostomy
with resection of small intestine, a significant decrease
in levels of serum sodium, serum potassium and serum
chloride was observed in the postoperative period but
their levels remained in normal range, except for serum
sodium which was below normal on postoperative day 5.
The above observations must
be viewed in the context that these intestinal stomas
patients were receiving intravenous fluid and electrolytes
till the 3rd day postoperatively. It may, however be
noted that no patient was allowed to go into a fluid
deficit.
Serum electrolytes losses in
patients following creation of intestinal stomas have
been reported by several workers. (Gallagher et al,
1962; Kramer P, 1966; Clarke et al, 1967; Hill GL, 1967;
LO Nilsson et al, 1982; Pearl RK, Prasad ML et al, 1984;
G. Swaninger et al, 1991).
These losses if not adequately
replaced, may lead to electrolyte deficient status.
The findings in the present study are similar to the
previously reported findings. Since the study of serum
electrolytes in the stoma effluent was not done in this
study, relationships showing the quantitative loss of
electrolytes and serum electrolytes concentrations was
not possible.
CONCLUSION
The stoma output was found to
be higher in patients having ileostomy and was significantly
higher in patients who had additional ileal segment
resection done.
Serum sodium and serum chloride
levels in patients with ileostomy, especially ileostomy
with additional resection of ileal segment, showed a
significant decrease in serum sodium and serum chloride
levels on all days in the postoperative period as compared
to patients with no resection of ileum or those undergoing
colostomy.
Serum potassium level showed
a significant decrease in patients with ileostomy, especially
those having additional resection of ileal segment in
the postoperative period, on the 5th postoperative day.
Serum calcium and serum magnesium
concentration showed no significant change in the postoperative
period in all groups of patients.
The patients with colostomy
showed no significant change in serum electrolyte concentrations
in postoperative period.
In the group of patients, having
high output ileostomy (³ 1 litre/day), there was
a significant decrease in serum sodium and serum potassium
on the 5th postoperative day.
The mean serum sodium level
remained within the normal range on postoperative day
1, day 3 and day 5 in all groups of stoma patients,
except in patients having ileostomy with additional
resection of ileal segment and patients with high ileostomy
output (i.e. ³ 1 litre per day), in which serum
sodium level decreased below normal range by the 5th
postoperative day.
The serum levels of potassium,
calcium, magnesium and chloride remained within normal
range in the postoperative period in all groups of stoma
patients.
From this study, it can be concluded
that:
1. Patients undergoing colostomy have low stoma output
i.e. below 500 ml/day;they do not develop fluid or electrolyte
derangements in the early postoperative period and need
no monitoring.
2. Patients undergoing ileostomy have average stoma
output higher than colostomy patients i.e. around 500-600
ml/day; all these patients showed a fall in electrolyte
values in the early postoperative period but the mean
values tend to remain in the normal range.
3. Patients who underwent ileal resection in addition
to ileostomy, have a significantly higher stoma output.
These patients showed a significant fall in serum electrolyte
levels, especially of sodium, chloride and potassium.
Serum sodium values fell below normal range by the 5th
postoperative day.
4. Patients with high output stomas (>1000 ml/day)
developed significant derangement of serum electrolytes
namely sodium and potassium.
In conclusion on the basis of
this study, it is recommended that:
-In all ileostomy patients, serum electrolytes should
be routinely estimated on the fifth postoperative day.
- In all patients who undergo ileal resection along
with ileostomy or who have high ileostomy output, should
be closely monitored for electrolyte derangements from
the third postoperative day onwards.
-No definite regimen of serum electrolytes replacement
can be recommended. Replacements of fluids and electrolytes
have to be individually tailored based on postoperative
serum electrolyte monitoring.
REFERENCES
- Abbot, WE, Krieger H, Babb. Metabolic alteration
in surgical patients I. The effect of altering the
electrolyte, carbohydrates, and amino acid intake.
AMA Annals of Surgery, 1963; 138: 434.
- Addendum: Bernard Claude (1938): Cited by Sudrania,
S.P. (1966). Bischoff, E., et al (1963): Cited by
Sudrania, S.P. (1966). Wootton, I.D.P. Microanalysis
in Medical Biochemistry. 4th ed. Churchill; 1964.
- Aurbach, GD, Potts, JT (Jr.), Chase LR, and Melson
PH. Polypeptide hormones and calcium metabolism. Ann
Intern Med 1969; 70: 1243.
- Balakrishna BN, Banerjee AK. Serum Potassium in
surgical stress. Indian Journal of Surgery 1962; 24(1):
60-65.
- Benedict FG. A study of prolonged fasting. Publication
203, Washington, DC. Carnegie Institution of Washington
1915.
- Berry, REL, Iob V, Campbell, KN. Potassium metabolism
in the immediate postoperative period. Arch Surg 1948;
57: 470.
- Bodansky O (1949): Cited by Sudrania SP (1966).
- Carmichael D, Few J, Peart S, Unwin R. Sodium and
water depletion in ileostomy patients. Lancet 1986;
13: 625.
- Carmichael DJS, Unwin RJ, Few JD, et al. Sodium
depletion in ileostomy patients. Lancet 1986; ii:
364.
- Delin K, Fasth S, Andersson H, Aurell M, Hulten
L, Jagenburg. Factors regulating sodium balance in
proctocolectomized patients with various ileal resections.
Scand J Gastroenterol 1984; 19: 145-149.
- Echelberger and Hastings. Quoted by Rosenthal SM
and Herbert Tabor. In: Electrolyte changes and chemotherapy
Archives of Surgery 1945; 244.
- Elkinton JR and Winkler AW. Transfers of Intracellular
potassium in experimental dehydration. J Clin Invest
1944; 23: 93.
- Elkinton JR, Winkler AW and Danowski TS. The importance
of volume and toxicity of body fluids in electrolyte
shock. J Clin Invest 1947; 26: 1002.
- Fazio VW, Tjandra JJ. Prevention and management
of ileostomy complications. Journal of et Nursing
1992; 19(2): 48-53.
- Finnisterer U, Luehr HG and Goetz E. Electrolyte
studies in major abdominal surgery. Anaesthesteist
(Berl) 1976; 25(12): 563-571.
- Fowler DI, Cooke WT, Brooke BN, Cox EV. Ileostomy
and electrolyte excretion. Am J Dig Dis 1959; 4: 710-720.
- Franks K. Colectomy or resection of the large intestine
for malignant disease. Med Chir Trans 1889; 72: 211-232.
- Gallagher ND, Harrison DD, Skyring AP. Fluid and
electrolyte disturbances in patients with long established
ileostomies. Gut 1962; 3: 219-223.
- Hill GL, Goligher JC, Smith AH and Mair WSJ. Long-term
changes in total body water, total exchangeable sodium
and total body potassium before and after ileostomy.
Br J Surg 1975; 62: 524-527.
- Hill GL, Goligher JC, Smith AH, Mair WS. Long term
changes in total body water, total exchangeable sodium
and total body potassium before and after ileostomy.
Br J Surg 1975; 62: 524-7.
- Hill GL, Mair WSJ, Goligher JC. Cause and management
of high volume output salt-depleting ileostomy. Br
J Surg 1975; 62: 720-726.
- Jenkins MT, Giesecke AH and Johnson ER. Postoperative
patient and his fluid and electrolyte requirements.
Br J Anasth 1975; 47: 143.
- Kanaghinis T, Lurban M and Coghill NF. The composition
of ileostomy fluid. Gut 1963; 3: 322-338.
- Kaplan SA and Carmen FT (1959): Cited by Thakur
PS (1965). Study of serum electrolytes in diarrhoea
in infants and children with special reference to
season changes. A thesis for MD. (Paed.) Univ Indore.
- Kenney HJ, Compston J, Heynen G, et al. Calcium
Magnesium in subjects living with a permanent ileostomy.
Digestion 1983; 26: 131-136.
- King LR, Knowles HC, Jr. and McLaurin RL. Calcium,
phosphorous and magnesium metabolism following head
injury. Ann Surg 1973; 177: 126-131.
- Krane SM and Michael FH. Disorders of bone and
Mineral Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine,
Metabolism 16th Edition 2005; 2192.
- Lockwood JS and Randall HT. The place of electrolyte
studies in surgical patients. Bull New Y Acad ed 1949;
25: 228.
- Zimmermann B. Fluid and Electrolytes balance in
surgical patients. Christophers Text Book of Surgery.
Saunders & Co. 1972.
- Zimmermann, B. Pituitary and Adrenal functions
in relation to surgery. Surgical Clinics of North
America. 1965; 45: 299.
|