Abstract
The article explores how loneliness is a complex
and usually unpleasant emotional response caused
by the death of a spouse in the family. Lack of
companionship due to such an event impacts the
whole quality(1) of life of the remaining spouse
with special reference to women, both in the present
and extending into the future. The causes of loneliness
are varied and include social, mental or emotional
factors. The paper explores how the death of a
spouse contributes to loneliness, and is reflected
as a social pain. The research is based on the
vulnerability hypothesis, i.e. "Women are
more vulnerable than men due to the impact of
the death of one's spouse". In completing
the research, a total of 584 lonely widows and
widowers were randomly selected, and interviewed
through questionnaires. The paper denotes how
the state of being alone detaches the remaining
spouse from others.
Key words:
Loneliness. Vulnerability. Social pain. Death
event. Quality of life.
|
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Aim of
the study
The research reflects various aspects of the quality
of life of women and men after the death of a partner.
Loneliness as a social reality happens to women and
men mostly in later ages. The paper will also uncover
some of the commonalities and similarities of such loneliness
in Tehran City as a metropolitan composed of various
social classes, races, social backgrounds etc. The article
provides an overview of the theoretical perspectives
concerning such women and men after a death. It will
also reflect on relevant key themes and issues. Though
the body of literature and research in sociology has
touched various subject-matters, the pathological situations
of such loneliness has been ignored. The paper also
tries to cite the identifiable stages/phases of human
development and the quality of life of such people.
It aims to reflect loneliness and death event in life
cycle (2) by portraying the period as a time of loss,
and as a life condition which stands in isolation from
the rest of couples' lives. We will see such loneliness
transition in terms of new roles and the lost roles.
However, loneliness as a potential beginning and a new
experience, will be explored and elicited. The article
also tries to reflect a perspective of how to make later
years of life worthwhile and successful for today's
and tomorrow's lonely women and men.
Introduction
Loneliness appears as an effect of marital dissolution
or death of a partner worldwide; in some cases it happens
due to divorce, and in most cases, as a natural event,
it appears because of the death of a spouse. Research
shows that in both cases, women tend to suffer long-term
negative social and economic consequences while men
do not (Neubeck et al., 1996, 478). While marital dissolution
tends to improve men's standard of living, the ratio
of income of women drops to a large extent. Also, the
widows' social relations drop since they are mostly
left in an isolated atmosphere. So far as Iran and many
other developing societies are concerned, the extent
of lonely women's decline in economic status is quite
considerable. The greatest decline following the death
of a partner occurs for women whose pre-widowhood family
incomes were high (before the death of the husband).
Under such conditions, women suffered a 71-percent drop
in income in the U.S. (Weitzman, 1985, 251). Researchers
have also demonstrated that in many countries including
Iran, the economic effects of widowhood are just as
disadvantageous for women as divorce, i.e. their poverty
rate tends to increase as compared to their pre-widowhood,
and before the death of their husbands (Hurd et al.,
1989, 177). While many husband-lost women in developing
countries such as Iran do not have any social security
at all, in the developed world like the U.S., widows
under the age of 60 are more likely to fall into poverty.
That is because in many insurance policies, greater
benefits accrue to an older widow (Holden et al., 1991).
Upon losing a husband, women may experience a whole
range of emotions including chaos, anger, resentment,
denial and disbelief. This may be followed by intense
grief, and a search for the lost person, and that usually
happens in every society. Eventual acceptance of the
death of one's partner can lead to depression and apathy.
To successfully survive, the lonely woman or man has
to recognize her/his life in an entirely new and unexpected
way (Bernardes, 1997, 104). Under the hard social and
economic conditions, many, especially women, fall into
deep poverty from which the only escape is one's own
death. Such a status may be more severe even in the
industrial societies where the network of family relations
does not function in a strong manner.
As a social phenomenon, loneliness must have been in
existence as long as socially-regulated marriage. The
consequences of loneliness are many and grave. Between
birth and death of a person, the most important event
in life is marriage; it changes the personalities, the
attitudes and lifestyle of women and men. Marriage is
entered into with great hopes and expectations. On the
contrary, family dissolution due to the death of a partner,
and the failure of marital life, has serious repercussions
on the individual, family and the community. Much research
and many observations have shown the negative results
of loneliness after the death a partner. In a way, dissolution
of marriage in the form of loneliness brings about personal,
familial and social disorganization, the effects of
which are more severe for women (Pothen, 1996, 26, 180,
182).
On the basis of research done, as a result of the emotional3
crises to which lonely women have been subjected, many
develop symptoms of personality disorganization. These
psycho-sociological manifestations include suppressions,
repressions, regressions, ambivalent motivations, loss
of self confidence, doubts, indecisions, nightmares
etc. As a whole, loneliness for both women and men is
nearly always a tragedy.
In the present article, the author tries to find out
the socio-economic background of the partner-lost women
and men, and know as to how far the age, education,
income etc. affect their new life course. Likewise,
through the research, the author hopes to trace the
adjustment process of the widows in starting a new life.
Loneliness as an institutionalized way of compulsory
ending of a marriage, is demonstrated differently in
various cultures and societies (Devir, 1998, 29). Howsoever,
losing a husband is the largest social and emotional
loss which the women face and suffer from it in the
course of their ordinary life. It is initially an experience
which we must live with, and secondly, it is a social
condition which we should get used to, and put up with
(Sadrusadat et al., 1999, 364).
Assuming that widowhood is such a major feature of later
life, it is surprising to discover that research on
the lives of older widows is so scarce 5(Bernard, 2000,
127). Under such conditions, the author was motivated
to demonstrate a sociological perspective of the lonely
women and men in Tehran. However, loss and bereavement
felt by such lonely women and men, though problematic,
is worth probing. The vast quantity of problems faced
by widows in society, convincingly portrays widowhood
as an experience fraught with poverty, ill-health, loneliness,
grief and readjustment. However, poverty has many causes
and manifestations, making it difficult to describe
with a single indicator with reference to partner-lost
women and men (Jaiyebo, 2003, 111). To better understand
and identify the problem, the whole scenario needs scientific
sociological research.
Methodology
The research techniques used in the present survey for
specific fact-finding, and operations to yield the required
social data, have been of a mixed-method strategy of
investigation. While the main technique of study in
this research is administering questionnaires, the author
used interview method where necessary as well. Documents
and books as major sources of evidence were used too,
as primary source materials. While so far lesser attention
has been paid to the loneliness studies in Iran, in
the theoretical section, the author has referred to
various theories and approaches, literature review and
so forth. The survey based on questionnaire- design,
attitude measurement and question wording, were as well
accompanied by face to face interviews where necessary.
In completing the research, lonely women and men were
randomly selected, and for whom the questionnaires were
filled in. Eventually 584 questionnaires were elicited
and extracted. However, in completing the present research,
and to produce a reliable and valid work, the procedure
of research was followed through the fundamental methods
mentioned. The research is based on the vulnerability
hypothesis, i.e. "Women are more vulnerable than
men due to the impact of the death of one's spouse".
Theoretical Analysis
It is often thought that loneliness is a common problem
everywhere regardless of race, religion, poverty or
affluence, geographical position etc. One of the main
constraints of the lonely women and men, especially
in countries like Iran, is their social isolation which
highly stems from cultural4 norms and values prevalent
in the society.
Loneliness is also reflected as a psycho-social transition
in which the phenomenon is seen as a disruption to an
accustomed way of life. Individuals will cope differently,
depending on their personality, culture, education and
social status (Kimmel, 1995, 48).
Increasingly, research on older lonely women and men
is beginning to consider issues of reciprocity and/or
exchange. In this model, older women are not seen as
powerless victims. Social exchange theory (Antonucci,
1985) identifies loss of reciprocity as a condition
under which social support may have negative consequences.
For example, the support given to older partner- lost
women, particularly by family, often leaves them in
the role of passive recipients, or patients receiving
treatment, and can leave them feeling powerless and
dependent. Other social scientists like Watanabe, Green
and Field (1989), who looked at the well-being of older
partner- lost women linked to support, also found that
too much support and lack of reciprocity had a negative
effect on the women, perhaps because they felt they
had less control. Such a focus on reciprocity allows
us to see older widows as active participants in their
social world, and thus builds in them the possibility
of growth.
From the demographic perspective, the process of ageing
is often confounded with other associated factors, such
as, deteriorating physical health, poor nutrition, bereavement,
social isolation and depression (Kuper and Kuper, 1996,
10), - all likely at the stage of losing a partner.
That is to say, all the above situations are mostly
experienced by the older lonely women and men in any
society. To better elaborate the subject-matter, sociologists
discuss the social changes brought about as successive
generations of people pass through life's stages, i.e.
one of them being widowhood (Keller, 1994, 131). Widowhood
and the solitude caused by that is also a period of
change and new challenges. It is a crisis for many women
and men. It is a time for re-evaluating what has been
accomplished so far, and for deciding what can realistically
be achieved in the years remaining.
Another theory indicates that: as longevity is greater
than the past, the number of widows and widowers depending
on the timing and variance of death rates, are more
than their overall level. If the ages of bride and groom
at marriage are the same, and males and females are
subject to the same life table, then according to present
mortality trends, widowhood would diminish. But, higher
age at marriage of men, and specially the superior survivorship
of women, introduces a strong element of asymmetry or
lack of correspondence that makes the number of widows
far greater than the number of widowers (Bongaarts,
1995,8). However, men and women are born, get married,
and eventually die single. Regardless of divorce as
a cause of marital dissolution, a marriage persists
until the death of one of the spouses, and that is when
the state of widowhood, or widowerhood appears.
To further discuss the theoretical perspectives of later
life widowhood, (Blau, 1973, 13) saw widowhood as a
''role-less status'', lacking any culturally prescribed
rights and duties towards others in the social system.
On the other hand, Ferraro also in 1984 identified some
changes within family roles in the early stages of widowhood,
particularly between mothers and daughters, when the
daughter might take on the ''mothering'' role for a
period of time. However, the effects of ''role loss''
in widowhood as Ferraro found, were not consistent,
but were more likely to be the result of other factors
surrounding widowhood, such as poverty, ill health,
and/or very old age, rather than widowhood per se. Nevertheless,
older women, though losing the role of ''wife'', compensate
for this loss by adopting to other roles. By using these
theoretical ideas, we can explore the cause-and-effect
reflections of change in later life widowhood. Finally,
life-cycle theory rests on the belief that normal families
go through normal stages of birth, growth, and decline.
Marriage initiates the family, the arrival of children
develops and expands it, their departure contracts it,
and it ends with the death of one of the spouses (Bilton,
et al., 2002, 255).
Literature Review
Through the review of relevant literature, the author
was enabled to design his research. In this review,
some research journals, books, dissertations, theses
and other sources of information were consulted. Hence,
the main planned research was preceded by a review of
related literature, followed by some of the works done
by others. However, literature review helps the researcher
to prescribe and define the proposed problem (Koul,
1993, 84).
So far as the author has investigated, much of the research
on later -life loneliness has been conducted in the
developed world in the 1970s and 1980s. The focus of
the research has mainly been on the problems of loneliness
and the support systems available for the lonely elders,
and in many cases, studies were conducted within three
years of the death of a spouse (Chambers, 1994). However,
much of the literature on lonely women and men in the
1980s would be better construed as literature on "widows
in bereavement".
The overall review of the literature indicates that
lonely elders are a homogeneous group; and widowhood
is synonymous with the acute state of bereavement. Older
widows being not self-determining, are lonely and isolated.
Generally speaking, elderly loneliness has been found
out as a period of decline.
More recent qualitative research (Pickard, 1994) and
others have started to question some of the prevailing
myths of widowhood, i.e. some of the numerous stereotypes
and assumptions surrounding loneliness etc.
Extensive relevant literature reflects the fact of elderly
loneliness as a major stressful life event (Holmes et
al., 1967). On the other hand, Martin-Matthews (1991,
30) reports that a major characteristic of the Canadian
widowhood research is its stress-related nature, with
a focus on the event of becoming a widow. However, widowhood
is referred to, as the loss of a spouse, namely, a life
event which requires most adjustment. Eileen Jones-Porter
(1994) suggests that when it is assumed that the death
of a spouse is a stressful event, researchers are more
likely to frame data collection in terms of grieving
and coping.
When we listen to the older lonely women and men talking
about their present lives, they first express the difference
that older women face in later life, and second, how
their experience is shaped both by their own life expectation
and the expectations of others. However, the challenges
faced by the partner-lost women and men may include:
family ties, friendship,
residence, social interests, financial issues, loneliness,
poor health, solo/alone living, and sometimes lack of
confidence.
Although the lonely women and men used to comprise the
largest group of the elderly people in the industrial
world in the last three decades, many Asian countries
including Iran are appearing the same in recent years.
However, while the industrial societies have developed
their social security systems to protect and handle
the elderly widows and widowers, the developing societies
including Iran, have a long way to go, to be able to
handle these people favourably. It is remarkable that
although the number of widows is increasing more due
to the socio-demographic changes that have occurred,
yet, very little information of these vulnerable people
is within reach (Kinsella, 1996, 26). Therefore, to
obtain a picture of the myths and realities of the widows,
one must search a number of different sources of medical
profession, research done by sociologists, psychologists,
social workers, and many other different viewpoints.
However, in modern times, due to increasing socio-economic
developments, governments have compulsorily intervened
in the private affairs of families such as birth control
etc. Though they compassionately try to promote social
welfare, health and food standards, and quality of life
of the families (Ezazi,2002,16), yet, the problems of
the widows are not well recognized and touched, especially
in Iran.
Historical literature review on widows denotes that
in earlier centuries in the Western world, widows dominated
the category of women without husbands, and death was
a major source of instability in marriage. Estimates
assert that, from medieval times to the mid 19th century,
about half of those who married in their mid-twenties
had lost their partner before they reached 60, and another
view suggests that marriages in the last century were
as fragile as those today: in the 1960s, a third of
all marriages dissolved with the death of a partner
within twenty years of being formed (Chandler, 1991,
15). However, widows are seen as an historically vulnerable
group, with varied position due to their socio-economic
structure.
Widowhood in its radical context could be found and
followed in ancient India in the form of Sati5 wherein
widows were obliged to burn themselves on the cremation
ceremony/ funeral of their husbands. Though not practiced
in modern era, yet, it could be sought among the very
religious Hindus.
Gender
and Marital Status
One of the most paining social problems that has long
preoccupied sociologists of gender and mental health
is that women have higher rates of depressive disorders
than men due to the death of a partner. Recent studies
indicate that women are twice as likely as men to experience
such mental health (Kessler:2003). Similarly, in most
studies conducted, from the 1970s to the present, women
report significantly more symptoms of depression than
men (Rosenfield and Mouzon:2013).
The present survey mainly depends on vulnerability hypothesis,
with respect to the etiology of women's greater emotional
distress after the death of one's husband. They usually
express more emotional upset relative to men. By vulnerability
hypothesis it is meant that: "Women are more vulnerable
than men to the impact of the death of one's spouse".
However, while women tend to be more reactive to family-related
stress, men tend to be more reactive to employment-related
stress (Simon and Lively:2010). Several longitudinal
studies find that becoming married (and remarried) results
in a significant decrease in symptoms of depression,
whereas becoming divorced, widowed and losing spouse
results in a significant increase in these symptoms
of distress (Barrett:2000).
However, socio-structural, socio-psychological and socio-cultural
factors contribute to persistent gender, marital status
and quality-of-life differences in emotional well-being
of women and men after the death of one of the partners.
Loneliness after the death of one of the two spouses
has also been described as a social pain; it is meant
to alert an individual of isolation, and motivate her/him
to seek social connections (Cacioppo:2008).
Gender Differences in Loneliness
Women in the industrialized world living seven to eight
years longer on average than men do, is more or less
becoming apparent in developing societies, and such
a gap is widening further and further for the Iranian
elderly lonely women too. This simple fact has many
implications for the society's social structure. For
example, there are five times as many widowed women
in the U.S. as there are widowed men. Likewise, since
women tend to marry older men in Iran as in many other
societies, they are much more likely to be widowed during
a large portion of their old age. As investigated in
countries like the U.S., by their 65th birthday, about
25% of married women will be widowed; and half of the
remaining ones will be widowed by age 75. Only one man
in five will lose his wife during the same time span
(Clausen, 1986, 55). Putting it another way, for people
aged 65 or older, 75% of men, but only 40% of the women
were living with their spouse (U.S. Bureau of the Census,
1990).
The experience of loneliness itself is different for
women and men. Either of the partners after separation,
i.e. loss of one spouse, will begin a difficult life,
especially at the initial stages, and either woman or
man will experience different phases/aspects, depending
on one's social, familial and cultural conditions(Asgari,
2001, 315). In some ways, it is more difficult for men
to adjust to, for they, not only lose their wives, but
a system of domestic support is impaired as well; one
that they have always taken for granted. As many men
currently in their sixties and seventies tend to be
unfamiliar with cooking and household chores, so partner-lost
lonely men may experience physical decline due to skipped
meals and poor nutrition. Loneliness also clashes with
men's self-definitions as independent and resourceful.
They are not accustomed to asking for help, so they
may get less assistance than they need from relatives
and friends, because they are not seen as "needy".
Among those over the age of 65, rates of suicide are
much higher for widowed men than for those whose wives
are still alive (Keller, 1994, 148). Though in this
regard, there is not clear statistical evidence in Iran,
but the case is very close to that of an industrial
society with special reference to Tehran.
At the same time, remarriage however, being predominantly
a male prerogative, for both demographic and cultural
reasons, in 1981, there were only twenty-three unmarried
men aged 65 and older for every one-hundred unmarried
women in an industrial society like the U.S. which could
be generalized to other developing societies like Iran.
In addition, older men still have the further option
of marrying younger women. As a result, men aged 65
and older are eight times more likely to remarry than
women at this age (Horn, 1987). Interestingly, social
status affects remarriage rates among the widows and
widowers in opposite ways. The more education a woman
has, and the higher her income, the less likely she
is to remarry, while the reverse is true for men.
Statistically speaking, about half the women householders
in Africa, Asia, the Pacific, and the industrialized
regions are partner-lost. This is generally due to the
trend for women to marry older men in most developing
regions, and to greater female longevity.
Fewer Lonely Elders in
Future
As life expectancy for both sexes is rising, the proportion
of the elderly who are widowed at any given age will
decline sharply. Women will be in particular affected
because they are much more likely than men to be widowed.
Today, for example, just over one-half (52%) of all
South Korean women age 65 to 69 are lonely. This proportion
is expected to drop to 17% in 2050. In Thailand too,
32% of women in this age group who are widowed today,
is projected to drop to 17% in 2050. It is estimated,
among men aged 65-69, only 8% are widowers in South
Korea, and only 10% in Thailand. Since the proportions
of men widowed are already low, the decline will be
more modest for men than for women in future (East-West
Center, 2002, 85). So far as Iran is concerned, loneliness
will be increasing in the country for the next few decades,
and then will drop as happened to South Korea and Thailand.
Findings and Data Analysis
Abridged Table 1:
Classification of lost-spouse women/men by gender
in Tehran City (No.,%)
Abridged Table 2: Classification
of lost-spouse women/men by gender and the duration
of loneliness in Tehran City (No.,%)
Total |
584
|
100
|
92
|
15.75
|
178
|
30.48
|
130
|
22.26
|
67
|
11.47
|
51
|
3.73
|
32
|
5.48
|
16
|
2.74
|
18
|
3.08
|
Females |
395
|
67.64
|
52
|
8.9
|
107
|
18.32
|
87
|
14.9
|
47
|
8.05
|
42
|
7.19
|
30
|
5.14
|
15
|
2.57
|
15
|
2.57
|
Males |
189
|
32.36
|
40
|
6.85
|
71
|
12.16
|
43
|
7.36
|
20
|
3.42
|
9
|
1.54
|
2
|
0.34
|
1
|
0.17
|
3
|
0.51
|
Abridged Table 3: Classification
of lost-spouse women/men by age , gender and the state
of monthly pensions in Tehran City (No.,%)
Abridged Table 4: Classification of lost-spouse women/men
by age , gender and the state of safety/illness in Tehran
City (No.,%)
Abridged Table 5: Classification
of lost-spouse women/men by age , gender and the state
of medical insurance in Tehran City (No.,%)
Abridged Table 6: Classification
of lost-spouse women/men by age , gender and their state
of accommodation in Tehran City (No.,%)
Data Analysis
Out of the 395 (67.64%) female samples, 1 (0.17%) of
women declared that they had lost their husbands for
less than one year, 14 (2.4%) asserted that they had
lost their spouses for 6 to 10 years. Similarly, 19
(3.25%) of women denoted the loss of their husbands
between 11 and 15 years. In another group, 35 (5.99%)
of the sample women asserted to have lost their husbands
for 16 to 20 years. While 28 (4.7%) of women declared
that they had lost their spouses for 21 to 25 years,
41 (7.02%) of the sample women asserted the loss of
their husbands for 26 to 30 years. Finally, 236 (40.41%)
of the sample women asserted that the death of their
husbands had happened 31 years ago or more.
Out of the 189 (32.36%) sample men studied, the highest
number 147 (25.17%) is related to the men who had lost
their wives for 31 years or more. High rate of maternal
death and other health-related issues is responsible
for the high frequency of loss of wives among the men.
So far as the problems of the widows and widowers are
concerned out of the total 395 (67.64%) female samples,
177 (30.31%) stated their most serious problem as the
loss of spouse, 76 (13.01%) declared their problem as
the lack of enough income, 79 (13.53%) of the widows
expressed their problems stemming from illness, and
finally 63 (10.79%) of the sample women expressed their
problems as others.
Similarly, out of 189 (32.36%) of the total male respondents,
111 (19.01%) declared their most serious problem as
the loss of their wives, 32 (5.48%) suffered from inadequate
income, 25 (4.28%) expressed their problem as suffering
from some illness, and at last 21 (3.6%) declared their
problems as others.
Some findings denote the quality of life of those who
lost their spouses. Out of 395 (67.66%) female sample
respondents, 141 (24.14%) suffered from social isolation,
148 (25.34%) suffered from material poverty, 35 (5.99%)
had limited relationships with friends, and finally
71 (12.16%) of the females expressed to have limited
relationships with the relatives.
As far as the male respondents are concerned, out of
the total 189 (32.36%) male samples, 92 (15.75%) suffered
from social isolation, 17 (2.91%) suffered from material
poverty, 27 (4.62%) had limited relationships with friends,
and 53 (9.08%) stated to have limited relationships
with relatives.
Similarly, out of 395 (67.64%) of the female samples
who had lost their husbands, only 10 (1.71%) were positive
to reside in nursing homes, whereas 367 (62.84%) did
not like to live in nursing homes, and finally 18 (3.08%)
stated that they to some extent like to stay in nursing
homes. Similarly, out of the 189 (32.36%) of male respondents,
19 (3.25%) were positive, and 149 (25.51%) were negative
to stay in nursing homes, and finally 21 (3.6%) to some
extent preferred to stay in nursing homes.
So far as leisure time pursuit of the widows and widowers
is concerned out of the total number of 395 women, 133
(22.77%) preferred to participate at religious meetings,
similarly, the same number of 133 (22.77%) used to spend
their leisure time by visiting their children, 26 (4.45%)
nursed their grandchildren, 39 (6.68%) used to spend
their leisure time by seeing their kin, and 64 (10.96%)
by other means. As far as male respondents in this category
are concerned, out of a total of 189 lonely men, 30
(5.14%) expressed to spend their leisure time in religious
meetings, 67 (11.47%) stated to spend their leisure
time by visiting their children, 12 (2.05%) used to
spend it by nursing their grandchildren, 14 (2.4%) used
to spend their leisure time by visiting kin, and finally
66(11.3%) stated as others.
The survey tried to measure the feelings of such lonely
women and men. Out of 395 such female sample respondents,
183 (31.34%) asserted to feel isolated and lonely, 32
(5.48%) felt poor, 107 (18.32%) used to feel dependent,
and finally 73 (12.5%) stated to feel fortunate and
happy. In the males section, out of 189 without - spouse
men, 120 (20.55%) stated the feeling of isolation and
loneliness, 15 (2.57%) stated to feel poor, 35 (5.99%)
felt dependent, and finally 19 (3.25%) stated to feel
fortunate and happy.
Discussion
As a result of the death of one of the spouses, the
remaining other spouse, particularly the woman, faces
various social, economic, psychological and emotional
constraints. Therefore, widowhood is strongly associated
with poor mental health (Das, Friedman and McKenzie:
2008). The state of having lost one's spouse to death
could leave the wife with increasing problems regardless
of where it happens. If we go back in history, widows
in many cultures used to wear black for the rest of
their lives to signify their mourning. Though it has
been loosened in many societies and cultures, yet many
widows comply with that. In the meantime, and as far
as the remaining female spouses are concerned, their
social networks are severely and negatively affected.
Such an invisible group of women are usually excluded;
they are painfully absent from the statistics of many
developing countries. In such countries the exact number
of such women (widows), their ages and other social
and economic aspects of their lives are unknown.
Widows or those who lost their husbands comprise a significant
proportion of all women; ranging from 7% to 16% of all
adult women (UN: 2001). However, older women are far
more likely than older men to be widowed. The proportion
of which in Western Asia where Iran also is situated,
is 48% for women aged 60+ as compared to 8% for men
aged 60+ between 1985-1997. As far as women are concerned,
the maximum proportion is 59% for women in Northern
Africa and 39% in developed regions of the world. Similarly,
as far as men are concerned, the lowest proportion is
7% in Africa and 14% in Eastern Europe. However, in
order to achieve real advancement, women who have lost
their husbands need support to get organized.
Conclusion
Not only in Iran, but across the globe, the women who
have lost their husbands share two common experiences:
a loss of social status and reduced economic circumstances.
Even in developed countries the older generation of
widows, those now over 60, may suffer a dramatic, but
subtle change in their social position. Similarly, the
monetary value of widows' pensions is a continuing source
of grievance, since the value often does not keep up
with fluctuations in the ever-changing cost-of-living
indices. A global overview indicates that countries
like India has the largest recorded number of widows
in the world, 33 million, (10% of the female population,
compared to only 3% of men); it is creating increasing
problems for such women. Iran too, is in the same position
relative to its population.
The data collected and their analysis, all reflecting
different dimensions of the quality of life of those
who lost their partners in Tehran, could help plan their
lives in a better way; particularly under the circumstances
that life expectancy is ever increasing, and women in
their later life get the chance to remain alone for
a longer course of time. As a result, many of the lonely
women expressed satisfaction with their quality of life,
and challenged the view that widowhood is a period of
decline. They acknowledged that many changes had occurred
in their lives. Many of them also acknowledged that
they often were alone and isolated. Most of the widows
studied, recognized that there had been changes from
their married lives, adjusting to the new phase of life,
network of friends, relatives, neighbours etc. The spouse-
lost women surveyed, expressed that they had undergone
a transition to another phase in their lives with new
values and standards; some reflected positive aspects
of their lives, while some dimensions caused them distress.
Further research about such silent groups of elder women
needs to be carried out; to listen to their voices and
their needs in order to improve their quality of life
and so forth.
End Notes
Quality of life: The concept being rather new
in sociology, describes a social atmosphere in which
standard of living lies in economic progress of a given
society. In the course of quality of life, on a comprehensive
and planned basis, however, social economy, social well-being,
family happiness, national planning etc. could be expected
and accessible. Quality of life also denotes to the
manner in which an individual or group lives. It is
currently used in a variety of contexts such as sociology,
family, economics etc. The notion of quality of life
among its other applications, is used to describe and
distinguish between rural and urban, married and widowed
life etc. Quality of life as a social manifestation
has constitutive social elements; including social,
economic and well-being indicators.
Life cycle: The process of personal change from
infancy through to old age and death, brought about
as a result of the interaction between "biological
events" and "societal events". The sociological
concept of life cycle does not refer to the purely biological
process of maturation, but to the transitions of an
individual through socially constructed categories of
age, and to the variations in social experiences of
ageing. For example, while men and women have very different
social experiences of biological ageing, the length
and importance of "childhood" varies among
cultures. In alternative sense, the life cycle of a
family is a process which includes courtship, marriage,
child-rearing, children leaving home, widowhood/widowerhood,
and finally dissolution of the family unit.
Emotional crises: The term used for emotional
behaviour in disconformity with, that expected from
an individual's age level within a given society. However,
emotional crises may be any disruptive life events,
possibly entailing the loss of important relationships
and social status, which may threaten the integrity
of the self and its social relationships. An indicative
list is bereavement, divorce, marriage, widowhood/widowerhood,
job loss or change, disability, retirement, migration
etc. which may involve stress and anxiety, are implicated
in the causation of some diseases and emotional crises.
They form an important area of study for sociology of
health and medicine. It is also counted as a central
factor for consideration in the fields of counselling
and psychotherapy.
Cultural norms and values: These characteristics
are essential for the survival of any society. Cultural
norms are the prescriptions which are serving as guidelines
for social action. Human behaviour exhibiting certain
regularities, are the product of adherence to common
expectations or norms. While deviation from norms is
punished by sanctions, norms are acquired by internalization
and socialization. The concept is central theories of
social order. On the other hand, social order and cultural
survival depend on the existence of general and shared
values which are regarded as legitimate and binding,
and act as a standard by the means of which the ends
of action are selected. The linkage between norms and
values is achieved through the process of socialization.
Sati or Suttee: A Hindu custom known as a solution
to widowhood was found in ancient India. In that, Hindu
women who had lost their husbands were obliged to commit
suicide on the funeral pyres of their dead husbands.
There are a number of explanations for this practice.
Sati has an economic basis. It was customary in India
for a husband's property to be distributed between his
mother and his sons. The widow, not having any means
to live on, and no support, her only option was suicide.
Another explanation expresses Sati as a part of Hindu
culture, and the caste system. It is an act of self-sacrifice
to assist the spiritual progress of the husband after
death, and was practised more by higher caste women
(Chandler, 1991, 17).
References
Antonucci, T., 1985, 'Personal Characteristics, Social
Support and Social Behaviour', in R. H. (ed.), Handbook
of Ageing and Social Sciences, New York, Van Nostrand
Reinhold.
Asgari, H., 2001, Role of Mental Health in Marriage,
Marital Life, and Divorce, P. 315, Tehran, Gofteman
Publishers.
Barrett, A.E., 2000, Marital Trajectories and Mental
Health. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 41, 451-464.
Bernard, M., et al., 2000, Women Ageing, P.127, New
York, Routledge.
Bernardes, J., 1997, Family Studies, P.104, New York,
Routledge.
Bilton, T., et al., 2002, Introductory Sociology, P.255,
New York, Macmillan.
Blau, Z., 1973, Old Age in a Changing Society, P.13,
New York, Franklin Watts.
Bongaarts, J., et al., 1995, Family Demography, P.8,
Oxford, Clarendon Press.
Boyen, JO., 1993, Families, P.53, London, Gaia Books
Limited (UNESCO Publishing).
Cacioppo, John; Patrick William, 2003, Loneliness: Human
Nature and the Need for Social Connection, New York:
W.W. Norton and Co.
Chandler, J., 1991, Women Without Husbands, P.15, London,
Macmillan Education Ltd.
Chambers, P., 1994, "A Biographical Approach to
Widowhood", Generation Review, 3, 4 :8-12.
Clausen, J. A., 1986, The Life Course: A Sociological
Perspective, P.55, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice- Hall.
Das, J., J. Friedman and D. Mackenzie, 2008, "Mental
Health Patterns and Consequence: Results from Survey
Data in Five Developing Countries". World Bank
Economic Review 23(1): 31-55. 25
Devir, U., 1998, Divorced
Women, P.29, New Delhi, APH Publishing Corporation.
De Beauvoir, Simone, 1972, Old Age, P.440, (Translated
into Persian by M. A. Toosi, ed.1991) Tehran , Shabaviz
Publishers.
East-West Center, 2002, The Future of Population in
Asia, P.85, Honolulu , Hagadone Printing Company.
Ezazi, S., 2002, Family Violence (Battered Women), P.16,
Tehran, Sali Publishers.
Ferraro, K., 1984, "Widowhood and Social Participation
in Later Life", Research on Ageing 6: 451-68.
Holden, K., 1991, "The Economic Costs of Marital
Dissolution", Annual Review of Sociology 17: (51-78).
Horn, J. C. and J. Meer: 1987, The Vintage Years: Psychology
Today 21(5):
76-90.
Holmes, T. H. and R. H. Rahe, 1967, "The Social
Readjustment Rating Scale", Journal of Psychosomatic
Research, 11: 213-218.
Hurd, M., et al., 1989, The Wealth and Poverty of Widows,
P.177, Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Jaiyebo, O., 2003, "Women and Household Sustenance:
Changing Livelihoods
and Survival Strategies in Peri-urban Areas of Ibadan",
Environment and Urbanization 15(1): 111.
Jones-Porter, E., 1994, "The Life World of Older
Widows: the Context of Lived
Experience", Journal of Women and Ageing 7, 4:
31-46.
Keller, S., et al., 1994, Sociology, P.131, London,
McGraw-Hill, Inc.
Kessler, R.C., 2003, Epidemiology of Women and Depression.
Journal Affective Disorders, 74, 3-15.
Kimmel, D., 1995, Adulthood and Ageing, P.48, London,
John Wiley. 26
Kinsella, K., 1996, "Demographic Aspects",
Epidemiology in Old Age, London, BMJ, PP. 32-40.
Koul, L., 1993, Methodology of Educational Researchers,
P.84, Delhi, Vikas Publishing House Ltd.
Kuper, A. and J. Kuper, 1996, Social Science Encyclopaedia,
P.10, London, Routledge.
Martin-Mathews, A., 1991, Widowhood in Later Life, P.30,
Toronto, Butterworths.
Neubeck, K. J., 1996, P.478, Sociology, New York, McGraw-Hill
Inc.
Pickard, S., 1994, "Life After a Death: the Experience
of Bereavement in South Wales", Ageing and Society,
14: 191-214.
Pothen, S., 1996, Divorce PP.26, 180 and 182, Bombay,
Vikas Publishing House.
Rosenfield, S. and Mouzin, D., 2013, Gender and Mental
Health. In C.S. Aneshnsel, J.C. Phelan, and A. Bierman
(Eds), Handbook of Sociology of Mental Health (2nd ed.,
PP.277-298), New York: Kluwer.
Sadrusadat, S. J., et al., 1999, "Familial Life,
Retirement, and the Years of Later Old Age", The
First International Conference on Ageing, Tehran, October
1999,Vol. II.
Simon, R. W., and Lively, K., 2010, Sex, Anger, Depression,
and Social Forces, 38, 1543-1568.
Tinker, A.: 1997, Older People in Modern Society (Longman,
London), pp. 231-232.
United Nations, Division for Advancement of Women, Department
of Economic and Social Affairs, 2001.
US Bureau of Census: 1990, Current Population Reports:
Series (US Government Printing Office, Washington DC),
20 pp.
Watanabe, S. Green, R. and S. Field: 1989, 'Social Support
Coverage and Wellbeing of the Elderly Widows and Married
Women', Journal of Family Issues, 10pp. 33-51.
Weitzman, L., 1985, The Divorce Revolution: The Unexpected
Social and Economic Consequences for Women and Children
in America, New York: Free Press.
|